|
Post by serrakunda on Apr 7, 2014 16:01:08 GMT
Had a meeting with education officer this morning, despite reports from placing LA I have recently obtained, which give very clear diagnosis of ASD and dyspraxia, including the assessment methods used, and current GPs categoric statement that there is nothing on Simba's actual medical record which 'un diagnoses' him, she is still refusing to accept that ASD is his diagnosis.
I feel we have no option but to request a new assessment. GP is more than happy to refer, and is of the view Simba is ASD. Because I've never been through these formal assessments before I was just wandering what our role as parents is in providing information about behaviors etc. I'm reluctant in some respects to go down this route as it seems to me the evidence I have is clear, and I don't really want to put him through it. I don't feel I have much choice, but his more significant behaviours are outside of school, at home and with friends, I assume this must form part of the assessment?
|
|
|
Post by donatella on Apr 7, 2014 16:13:21 GMT
The dx of Asd has to come from camhs or paed. If you've got that in writing then education officer's opinion (is that EP? ) is irrelevant.
Excuse me if I'm getting confused but are you asking about getting a diagnosis or appropriate support in school?
|
|
|
Post by sooz on Apr 7, 2014 16:32:04 GMT
Hi there.
Certainly here, my input has been requested (over and over actually) and the school has also been asked for their input too. I've been asked many questions about ds and to give my view. Ds has only been involved when he's needed to be, ie once all information gathered in.
|
|
|
Post by serrakunda on Apr 7, 2014 16:41:51 GMT
The problem is that I have a collection of reports from different people, placing LA swear blind to me there is nothing else, we have no history with the professionals here, the reports are old and there has been progress in some areas.
The biggest sticking point is that there is a community paeds one page letter written to the then GP, which states that his traits no longer merits a formal diagnosis of ASD, this seems to have followed a routine LAC medical, not a formal assessment or diagnostic process. This is dated 6 months after two reports I have which quite clearly state the diagnosis is ASD and dyspraxia. I recognise the child I see in these reports as the little boy who came home. I, and my current GP are mystified as to how the community paed could arrive at this conclusion. Although this letter is not included in Simba's medical records, it was attached to his statement although I only saw it three weeks ago.
My concern is not so much his current school provision but that we have to decide on secondary school this year, if we cannot agree on what his actual diagnosis is, I'm concerned about getting access to the right support at secondary level, and also his entitlements to future services and possibly benefits. I've no doubt that Simba is at the lower, more able end of the spectrum, but I've equally no doubt that his behaviourial traits impact on his ability to function in mainstream life. Current GP is very happy to refer to Camhs for an assessment.
|
|
|
Post by donatella on Apr 7, 2014 16:42:58 GMT
For everyone who's assessed both of mine I've written a report which I've emailed to them in advance. For the paed i got hold of his secretary and sent the info to her. Found that it helps them to have a good idea of background and behaviour before seeing my kids plus it means it avoids some awkward questions.
|
|
|
Post by donatella on Apr 7, 2014 16:51:19 GMT
Okay. Then imo the Asd dx is going to be important for when he goes to comp otherwise god knows where he'll end up. This is why we chased dx and statementing. Without dx his primary need would be deemed to be ebd - no high school ebd units here. We have to demonstrate that his primary need is Asd in order to access the right unit at comp level which is going to mean a change or school in y6. That's all up in the air at the moment.
How do they assess in your area? Here it's multidisciplinary and includes camhs, paeds, salt and ot. Dx then made via panel. One had ados and one didn't.
I sent the same report to camhs and paeds with a less detailed version to ot and salt.
Do watch though that you're not pushed down trauma/attachment route - that's what camhs tried to do with my kids.
|
|
|
Post by pluto on Apr 7, 2014 17:30:29 GMT
My child came without autism diagnosis, the papers to prove this, the asd team said no, an private expert said no. All neglect. I disagreed and refused to adopt without diagnosis because I was sure he had autism, I had worked many years with asd kids and recognise them. So i ended up here; www.autism.org.uk/our-services/diagnosing-complex-needs/referrals-and-assessment.aspx A 2 day assessment, child in one room being tested, I in the other answering questions. And I was right he did have autism (by than a relief as I knew but the professionals refused to believe me), and not a little bit (whatever that means). I remember we came in and there was a kitchen with washing machine, the first thing he did was 'loading' the washing machine, the candle on the table, a dish cloth, handsoap, a plant etc. The first thing I said was look at this, and apparently he has no autism . It was so easy for me to answer their questions, I had plenty of examples without having to think long.
The report they produced was very detailed and good, it has been very usefull when he changed schools, and when we moved.
|
|
|
Post by esty (archive) on Apr 7, 2014 19:48:03 GMT
I think it might be very helpful for Simba to be reassessed now he is home with you. Now the 'experts' will be getting a true picture of Simba especially with your input. I think for his future and for a true picture of his needs I would go ahead with reassessment. From how you have described Simba I'm sure you can sell an assessment to him on the grounds of how much he's developed. For his move to secondary I would ask for EP involvement and assessment and ask GP to refer to CAMHS and press the LAC/adopted child PPP to be used if necessary. Good luck.
|
|
|
Post by serrakunda on Apr 7, 2014 23:54:45 GMT
Does recording 300 episodes of Peppa pig count for anything?
The current obsession, may regret getting a sky box
|
|
Deleted
Deleted Member
Posts: 0
|
Post by Deleted on Apr 8, 2014 6:51:02 GMT
I agree with Esty, I think Simba should have a thorough assessment now he's been living with you for two years. He has probably come along in loads of areas and then other areas will be highlighted where you think he needs more help or support as you are the one who really know him best.
Ironically I have just, finished a very thorough assessment of EDD possibly being on the ASD spectrum. CAMHS are struggling to know what to do with her, so are assessing her for ASD if only to rule it out. I had two seperate sessions with their Autism specialist which was very thorough, massess of questions, asking about behaviours, friendships, schooling etc. Each session was for 2 hours, quite tiring, but very thorough, so she gets a full view of all behaviours.
She is now going to do the Autism tests with DD and will compile a report of her findings at the end to rule it in or out, or where she falls on the spectrum.
From what you've posted over the years Simba definately has ASD, but the testing will show what level and then you have a starting point to go forward and see what help he is likely to need at secondary school. Better to start now while you have the time to get it done, rather than wait until he is in secondary school and could be in the wrong one for his needs.
The only good thing in CAMHS favour is they do know a lot about Autism and ADHD etc, not so good on attachment, but definately cued up on ASD as they see a lot of kids with it daily.
|
|
|
Post by pluto on Apr 8, 2014 12:09:39 GMT
Peppa is just so typical, here we have curious George. My oldest just made a sweater in school, yellow with a flag (obsession also) on the front, and now he is making a yellow Hat, lol. (man with the yellow hat). He LOVES Mr. Bean also.
|
|
|
Post by serrakunda on Apr 8, 2014 12:13:47 GMT
I'd prefer Peppa Pig if she was a sandwich
|
|
|
Post by Ad-minnie! on Apr 8, 2014 13:59:53 GMT
Aspergers / Autism assessment usually involves taking detailed history from parents so your role is crucial. Even when someone is adult, information about their childhood is considered very important in diagnosis. So things like obsessions, interests, interactions with peers etc.
Having diagnosis will not just help with school support but also later with accommodation if it needs to be supported and with work etc.
The paed undiagnosing makes no sense at all. You can't suddenly not have it and also where are the assessments the paed used. You can't diagnose on one off assessment. Requires thorough look at behaviours and developmental history.
Sorry for you and Simba that you might have to go through more assessments :-(
|
|
|
Post by wibbley on Apr 8, 2014 16:05:41 GMT
I would go for re-assessment to clear it up once and for all. In fact, I would push for assessment at the Newcomen Centre (London) run by Gillian Biard. Top UK ASD/Aspie specialist running the top UK NHS diagnostic centre. They deal with many second opinions and the waiting lists are actually a lot shorter than many of the local routes (5mths wait to be seen there, 18-24mths locally here). The assessment is pricey and the referrer picks up the tab, so there may be reluctance to get the referral done. No one will be able to dispute a diagnosis made there. Their view is that ASD and attachment can run together, one does not exclude the other. Also that there is more than cause of ASD too. Which is rather helpful for our kids. A local assessment here would take about an hour and half, a good multi disciplinary would take several hours BUT all the kids I know who have had them (mine included) really enjoyed them. They are managed by specialists who want to get the best out of your child and not stress them out. My son is highly anxious but came out laughing clutching a balloon after almost 4 hours!! Go for it, the assessment shouldn't be arduous for your son at all. Though you will be exhausted
|
|
|
Post by littlemisscheerful on Apr 9, 2014 7:10:10 GMT
My GP was reluctant to re-refer my YD to Camhs, - she thought all her symptoms were synonomous with early trauma. I argued that if that were the case, we still need some help. I wrote a long list of all her behaviours that I was worried about, which she sent with referral. This was definitely helpful in the process. she was dx by paed, - her participation in the assessment was minimal (she sat on my lap and did a bit of pointing but no verbal). Paed dx her as ASD based on this short assessment and the questionnaires filled in by school and I. ED was assessed by Camhs, - she was in one room being assessed, I was next door doing the family history, what was she like when young etc, - She was 9 then. That was about 2 hrs I think. But I remember I made a comment that she wouldn't ask if she needed the toilet, so could they please offer her the opportunity,- that was deemed unusual and i think those little things add to the big picture. Re Peppa, ours is the Simpsons, - and watching the same episode of Coronation Street 3 times! Suggest cancelling series link - he probably won't even notice!!
|
|
|
Post by ham on Apr 9, 2014 12:55:49 GMT
as there seems to be confusion I would go with the assessment not just to help with secondary school but for when he becomes an adult.I made the mistake of not pursing some stuff for my dd ( we had so many assessment for therapy I did not follow up all the ones for diagnosis for some things. and to get a care package in place is a nightmare now she is an adult where as ds2 gets a good care package. I always now try to think what will help my youngsters in the very long term future as well as the short term future.
|
|
|
Post by serrakunda on Apr 9, 2014 15:36:31 GMT
Peppa is bacon on toast.
It's only the education officer that seems confused but as she is the one who writes the statement...... If she was is my house right now she would be crystal clear , autism central at the moment
But
I have written letter for school for OT referral. GP is very supportive and has asked for a letter setting out my concerns and will do referral to Camhs. Yes Ham I agree it's as much for his adult future as now.
|
|
|
Post by esty (archive) on Apr 9, 2014 17:36:56 GMT
Oh is she choosing the non ASD bit to protect the budget??? In which case definitely get him assessed. She sounds like she may be the Placement Officer and they hold the keys to the purse. she may think an ASD diagnosis would change what you want for him, ie more expense.
|
|
|
Post by shadow on Apr 12, 2014 8:57:17 GMT
interesting - I wasn't asked anything when shadette was assessed - in fact I didn't know she was being until a week after - (she was in the YPU) - but I gather there were many differing views about her and the psychologist is convinced she is on the spectrum - but the psychiatrist and senior CPN over ruled him and said it was "Lack of Parental Care" and pushed for her to be taken into care under order
|
|
|
Post by wibbley on Apr 12, 2014 16:02:08 GMT
Strange, parents views & observations are really important for diagnosis I would've thought. We certainly had to answer many many questions during our LOs assessment.
|
|